Manuscript Evaluation
-
Title reflects clearly the topic.
-
Abstract represents the paper contents.
-
Accuracy of collection of thorough literature (emphasis on continuity & recent literature). Check also adequacy of literature, Novelty of work reported i.e., originality of contribution, Clarity of objectives/aims.
-
Experimentation/Analysis.
-
Validation of results.
-
Significance of results.
-
Sufficiency of discussion.
-
Soundness & justification of conclusions drawn.
-
Length of paper
-
Writing style, organization & quality
-
Clarity of representation
-
Soundness of figures, tables & citations
-
Typographic errors
-
Grammatical Errors
-
Overall rating (Poor, Fair, Good, Very Good, Excellent).
Plagiarism should be less than 13 percent