Manuscript Evaluation

  • Title reflects clearly the topic.

  • Abstract represents the paper contents.

  • Accuracy of collection of thorough literature (emphasis on continuity & recent literature). Check also adequacy of literature, Novelty of work reported i.e., originality of contribution, Clarity of objectives/aims.

  • Experimentation/Analysis.

  • Validation of results.

  • Significance of results.

  • Sufficiency of discussion.

  • Soundness & justification of conclusions drawn.

  • Length of paper

  • Writing style, organization & quality

  • Clarity of representation

  • Soundness of figures, tables & citations

  • Typographic errors

  • Grammatical Errors

  • Overall rating (Poor, Fair, Good, Very Good, Excellent).

Plagiarism should be less than 13 percent